,

Potential Net Migration Index Falls in Middle East, Latin America

WASHINGTON, D.C. — People’s desire to migrate permanently to other countries rebounded slightly between 2013 and 2016, but Gallup’s Potential Net Migration Index (PNMI) shows adult populations would continue to grow only in Northern America, Europe (European Union and non-EU countries), and Australia, New Zealand and Oceania if everyone who wanted to move actually moved to where they wanted. At the same time, populations in sub-Saharan Africa, Latin America and the Caribbean, the Middle East and North Africa, and Asia would wither.

A migrant camp in Penas Blancas, Costa Rica, close to the border with Nicaragua on July 19, 2016. Hundreds of tents shelter Haitian, Congolese, Senegalese and Ghanaian migrants waiting to continue their journey to the United States.
Gallup’s Potential Net Migration Index
Potential change to the adult population through out– and in-migration, based on expressed desire
2010-2012 2013-2016 Change
Australia/New Zealand/Oceania +138 +162 +24
Northern America +53 +54 +1
Europe (other) +31 +42 +11
European Union +20 +21 +1
Southeast Asia -3 -2 +1
Middle East and North Africa +2 -3 -5*
East Asia -6 -6 0
South Asia -8 -7 +1
Commonwealth of Independent States -11 -9 +2
Latin America -14 -17 -3*
Sub-Saharan Africa -24 -25 -1
* Significant decline
Gallup World Poll

 

Gallup’s PNMI is the estimated number of adults who say they would like to move permanently out of a country if the opportunity arose subtracted from the estimated number who say they would like to move into it, as a proportion of the total adult population. The higher the resulting positive PNMI score, the larger the potential net adult population gains. The latest results include 156 countries or areas surveyed between 2013 and 2016 and are based on nearly 590,000 interviews. PNMI scores for 2010 to 2012 are based on surveys in 154 countries and areas and interviews with nearly 520,000 adults.

For the most part, not much has changed at the regional level since Gallup last calculated its PNMI scores. Scores fell significantly in only two regions, Latin America and the Middle East and North Africa (MENA). The decline in MENA is particularly worth noting because the score went from positive to negative for the first time — meaning the region would experience a net loss of adults.

However, it is important to look beyond these broad, regional patterns and look at scores at the country level because they don’t always mimic the region as a whole. For example, while sub-Saharan Africa overall scores a -25 PNMI, scores range from a +40 in Botswana to a -62 in Sierra Leone. And in non-EU countries in Europe, scores ranged from +173 in Switzerland (also the highest PNMI score in Europe) to -39 in Albania.

At the same time, some countries follow the same patterns as their region as a whole. In former Soviet states, for example, not one country posted a positive PNMI score. This is not to say that the situation has not improved in some countries. Russia’s score in 2010 to 2012 was -9, and it improved significantly to -4 in the most recent analysis period. The percentage of Russians who want to leave their country has been much lower in the past several years than it has been for most of the past decade — possibly reflecting a surge in patriotism after Crimea joined Russia in 2014.

Notable Increases, Declines in the European Union

Within the European Union, PNMI scores increased significantly only for Germany. The increase from +23 in the previous period to +41 in the current one coincides with the massive influx of migrants and refugees into the country beginning in 2015 and the growth in the country as a desired destination among potential migrants.

Elsewhere in the European Union, as the United Kingdom became a less desirable destination for potential migrants, it saw its PNMI score drop significantly from +53 to +39. Italy’s score dropped from +10 to -3 (the first time it has had a negative score), Poland’s dropped from -14 to -19 and Cyprus’ score declined from +71 to -5. Notably, in Greece, which has been the entry point to Europe for many migrants, there has been no change in its typically negative scores.

Venezuela Leads Losses in Latin America

The PNMI scores for Latin America as a whole worsened in the most recent analysis period, dipping lower to -17. Changes in populous countries such as Venezuela, which has teetered on the edge of economic and political collapse since 2013, are largely behind the sinking scores in the region. The country’s PNMI dropped from -9 between 2010 and 2012 to -20 between 2013 and 2016. Negative scores in Brazil and Mexico nearly doubled, likely reflecting the political and economic turmoil in those countries.

In Paso Canoas, Costa Rica, a child migrant waits on a bus to be taken to a shelter. CNN
Potential Net Migration in Latin America
Potential change to adult population from out- and in-migration, based on expressed desires
2013-2016
Belize +90
Costa Rica +21
Panama +19
Trinidad and Tobago +1
Argentina -2
Paraguay -7
Chile -10
Brazil -15*
Ecuador -15
Jamaica -19
Mexico -19*
Nicaragua -19
Venezuela -20*
Bolivia -22
Colombia -24
Puerto Rico -28
Peru -29
Guatemala -30
Dominican Republic -40
El Salvador -41
Honduras -43
Haiti -56
* Significant decline
Gallup World Poll

 

Bottom Line

While Gallup’s PNMI does not predict migration patterns, it does provide useful information about whom these countries are attracting around the world and the areas where they need to work to ensure they retain the talent already at home.

People’s desire to migrate showed signs of rebounding after bowing slightly in the wake of the Great Recession, but some countries, such as the United Kingdom, while remaining highly desired destinations, have lost some of their allure in that same period. While it has declined significantly, the U.K.’s positive PNMI score suggests the adult population would still grow through migration. Others, such as Germany, are even more desirable and would see larger influxes. The situation presents a double-edged sword for the United Kingdom, Germany and a host of other countries where native workers are aging faster than they are being born.

Survey Methods

Results are based on telephone and face-to-face interviews with nearly 590,000 adults, aged 15 and older, in 156 countries from 2013 to 2016. The 156 countries surveyed are home to 98% of the world’s population.

For most countries, aggregated sample sizes (across multiple years of surveys) range between 3,000 and 6,000 interviews. A total of 12,000 interviews were conducted in India, 17,578 in China and 8,000 in Russia.

The PNMI is measured on a scale of -100 (meaning the total adult population of the country would leave) to infinity (meaning the potential inflow of adult population to the country is unlimited and depending on the number of adults who want to move in from around the world). As with any survey-based estimate, the PNMI has a corresponding margin of error for each country, calculated using the standard error of the index. Sample size, size of the country and range in population projection weights affect the PNMI margin of error.

Gallup’s PNMI is based on responses to the following questions:

Ideally, if you had the opportunity, would you like to move permanently to another country, or would you prefer to continue living in this country?

(If “would like to move permanently to another country”) To which country would you like to move? [open-ended, one response allowed]

For more complete methodology and specific survey dates, please review Gallup’s Country Data Set details.